Material Breach of Contract Explained

Material Breach of Contract Explained

All Insolvency

What happens when a critical business agreement falls apart? A material breach of contract doesn’t just disrupt daily operations – it can unravel key partnerships, cause significant financial loss, and damage a company’s reputation.

When one party fails to uphold contractual obligations, the ripple effects can disrupt even the most well-structured agreements, leaving companies vulnerable and unsure of their next steps.

This legal guide is designed to provide you with clarity around the intricacies surrounding a material breach of contract.

What is a material breach of contract?

A material breach of contract is a significant failure by one party to perform a critical obligation under an agreement, ultimately undermining the purpose of the contract. This type of breach disrupts the core purpose of a contract and prevents the non-breaching party from fulfilling their responsibilities or achieving the intended outcomes. It can often justify terminating the agreement or seeking legal remedies, such as litigation or arbitration. To determine whether a breach qualifies as material, courts typically examine:
  • The extent of the breach: How significant is the failure in fulfilling key terms of the contract?
  • The impact on the non-breaching party: Does the breach prevent the other party from receiving the expected benefits of the contract?
  • Good faith and intent: Did the breaching party demonstrate a lack of effort or intent to meet their obligations?
  • Opportunities to remedy: Was there an opportunity to address and rectify the breach, and was this opportunity ignored?
  • Provisions of the contract: Does the agreement define specific obligations or outcomes as critical to performance?

Examples of material Breach of contract

Material breaches in commercial contexts can have far-reaching implications, often disrupting business operations and straining professional relationships. Understanding common breach of contract scenarios helps businesses recognise and address these critical issues effectively.

 

Below are key examples of material breaches in commercial settings:

  • Failure to Deliver Critical Products or Services
    For businesses reliant on timely delivery, a failure by one party to supply essential goods or services as specified in the contract can severely impact operations. 
  • Non-Payment for Goods or Services Rendered
    When a party fails to pay for goods or services as agreed, it constitutes a material breach that undermines trust and disrupts cash flow. 
  • Refusal to Perform Agreed-Upon Work
    A contractor’s outright refusal to perform agreed services, such as completing a construction project or implementing essential software, can leave the non-breaching party unable to meet their own objectives.
  • Delivery of Non-Compliant Products or Services
    Providing products or services that fail to meet the agreed-upon specifications can disrupt business goals. 
  • Violation of Exclusivity Agreements
    Breaching exclusivity terms in a contract – such as a distributor agreeing to sell a competitor’s products despite exclusivity obligations – can erode trust and undermine the original agreement’s intent.

Each of these examples highlights how material breaches go beyond minor deviations, fundamentally disrupting the objectives of a contract and forcing businesses to seek legal recourse or alternative remedies to protect their interests.

Material breach vs. minor (non-material) breach

A material breach occurs when one party fails to fulfill a fundamental term of the contract, rendering the agreement’s core purpose unachievable. This type of breach strikes at the heart of the contract, often causing irreparable harm or significant loss to the affected party.

 

On the other hand, a minor (non-material) breach refers to a failure to meet a less critical aspect of the contract without hindering its primary purpose. While it may still cause inconvenience, the overall contract remains intact and operational.

 

For example, if a vendor delivers a shipment slightly out of schedule but the products are functional and used without issue, this would typically qualify as a minor breach.

How to prove a material breach of contract

When a business faces a material breach of contract, the financial and operational impacts can be significant. Proving such a breach is essential to secure appropriate remedies, whether it’s compensation, specific performance, or termination of the agreement. 

 

Here are the key steps to consider to help substantiate your claim and protect your business interests:

  1. Review the contract terms: Review the agreement to identify key obligations and provisions integral to the contract’s purpose. Highlight the specific terms that have been violated by the other party.
  2. Gather evidence: Collect tangible evidence, such as emails, written agreements, invoices, or reports, that demonstrate the material breach.
  3. Demonstrate the impact: Assess how the breach has undermined the anticipated benefits of the agreement. Provide specific details like financial losses, operational disruptions, or reputational damage.
  4. Communicate the Breach: Send an official notice to the other party, describing the breach and its material nature. Maintain a written record of all correspondence to support future legal proceedings.

In many cases, legal advice and representation is required for substantial cases to ensure the best possible outcome.

 

With many years supporting businesses with both domestic and cross-border disputes, our litigation lawyers will help you achieve the most desirable result. Call today for your free consultation on 020 7467 3980.

Legal remedies for material breach of contract claims

The legal consequences vary based on the contract’s terms and jurisdiction, but courts generally offer specific remedies to address such breaches.

 

Below are some of the legal options available for material breach of contract claims:

  1. Contract Termination: The non-breaching party can terminate the agreement entirely, releasing them from further obligations and allowing them to seek alternatives.
  2. Monetary Damages: Courts may award compensation to cover direct losses (compensatory damages) and, in some cases, secondary losses like lost profits (consequential damages).
  3. Specific Performance: When monetary damages are insufficient, the court may order the breaching party to fulfill their contractual obligations, such as delivering a promised service or product.
  4. Rescission: The contract may be rescinded, meaning it is treated as if it never existed, and both parties are restored to their pre-contract positions.
  5. Legal Costs: The breaching party may also be required to cover the legal fees and costs incurred by the non-breaching party in pursuing remedies.

Material breach of contract - FAQ’s

Non-payment can constitute a material breach of contract under UK law if it significantly undermines the core purpose of the agreement.

 

Whether non-payment qualifies as a material breach depends on the terms of the contract and the importance of the payment obligation to the overall agreement. Courts will assess the severity of the breach and its impact on the non-breaching party when determining materiality.

The tax treatment of damages for breach of contract depends on the nature of the compensation. If the damages are compensatory in nature, intended to cover losses or restore the claimant to the position they would have been in had the contract been performed, they are generally not taxable.

 

However, damages awarded as a replacement for income, such as lost profits, may be subject to tax. Consulting a tax specialist or breach of contract solicitor is recommended to establish the correct position.

Under UK law, a third party may sue for breach of contract if the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 applies. This Act allows third parties to enforce contractual terms if the contract explicitly states their rights or if the agreement was intended to benefit them. Without such provisions, a third party has no legal standing to sue unless other exceptions apply.

Misrepresentation and breach of contract are distinct legal concepts. Misrepresentation occurs when a false statement of fact is made, inducing one party to enter into a contract.

 

A breach of contract, on the other hand, involves failing to fulfill agreed contractual terms. While they are different issues, misrepresentation may entitle an injured party to remedies like rescission or damages, separate from claims for breach of contract.

Yes, you can sue a company for breach of contract in the UK if it fails to fulfill its contractual obligations, resulting in harm or loss to you.

 

To succeed, you must demonstrate that a valid contract existed, the terms were breached, and the breach caused measurable damage. It is advisable to seek legal advice to ensure your claim is properly prepared with the necessary evidence.

Contact our breach of contract solicitors

Here at Summit Law, our breach of contract lawyers specialise in high-value and substantial cases, advising on claims ranging from £50,000 to multi-million-pound disputes. Our heavyweight litigation solicitors offer SME’s and enterprise organisations with first-class legal representation that’s results-driven and tailored to your unique requirements.

 

For your free initial consultation, please call our litigation lawyers today on 020 7467 3980. Alternatively, you can complete the enquiry form on this page.